Posts Tagged ‘Labour Party Marxists’

Article Supporting Mike by Labour Party Marxists

November 24, 2018

One of the groups opposing the anti-Semitism witch hunt in the Labour party is Labour Party Marxists. I think that Moshe Machover, the very respected Israeli academic, activist and defender of the Palestinians may be a member. Machover was one of those the Blairites and the Israeli lobby tried to throw out as an anti-Semite, before being faced with such massive condemnation from the party’s membership that they had to eat humble pie and reverse their decision. Machover is a man of immense integrity, who should never have been smeared, and it is absolutely right that the apparatchiks who did so should have been forced to rescind their decision. Unfortunately, there are thousands of others, who have not been so lucky to have the support he has.

Mike’s case is discussed in a long article posted on November 15 attacking the witch-hunt and its smears and victimization of a number of innocent, decent people, entitled ‘Anti-Zionism and Self-Censorship’. Mike has a section specifically dedicated to his case in the middle of the article. It begins

The case against Mike Sivier is intriguing, because he seems absolutely right when he claims that there is precious little evidence that supports his expulsion from the party. Even those claiming that Sivier is clearly anti-Semitic and have written long articles about his case cannot actually produce any real proof. In a piece entitled The ballad of Mike Sivier, the hostile author, Marlon Solomon, draws a long list of examples of Sivier’s ‘crimes’ – which basically amount to the fact that he was defending various people falsely accused of anti-Semitism.

The article discusses how Mike supported Ken Livingstone’s remarks about the Ha’avara agreement between the Nazis and Zionists, supported Jackie Walker and Tony Greenstein, and urged people to watch Al-Jazeera’s The Lobby, which exposed how the Israel lobby had manufactured the anti-Semitism ‘scandal’ in the Labour party.

Marlon Solomon, the writer of the nasty little piece attacking Mike, whines that “none of the above is now considered sufficient to expel someone from the Labour Party”. To which the writer of the article responds ‘ Quite right – it should not be’. It then goes on to note how Mike won a press complaint in August, 2018, against the Jewish Chronicle, which had smeared him as a Holocaust denier. It also notes how in February that same year the NEC had voted to lift Mike’s suspension if he underwent anti-Semitism training by the Zionist Jewish Labour Movement. Mike refused on the grounds that this would constitute a tacit admission of guilt, and the article agrees with his decision, stating that it is to his credit. The article then states that the NEC didn’t know what to do about Mike, and so passed his case on to the NCC.

The article states that Mike had no chance in front of this panel, as it’s dominated by the right. Its membership has been expanded from 11 to 25, and the article predicts that the six candidates put up by Momentum and the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy will probably win. But they will still me a minority, and the only member of the NCC to come out against the witch hunt is Stephen Marks of Jewish Voice for Labour. It goes on to state that the NCC, chaired by right-wing witch-hunter Maggie Cousins, voted to expel him on November 13th for 18 months, but still could provide no proof that he was an anti-Semite. The article states

As he writes on his blog, his requests to produce actual evidence were rebutted with “No comment”; “We’ve not provided evidence – it’s about the impact in the public domain”; and “This is about perception … It’s about how this is perceived by the Jewish community.”

They conclude

In other words, he has been expelled because his refusal to receive pro-Zionist training by the JLM makes the Labour Party look bad! This expulsion is clearly a travesty and should immediately be overturned by the NEC.

The article then moves on to discuss another case, that of Peter Gregson in the Edinburgh Labour Party, who is under investigation for writing a pamphlet entitled Israel Is A Racist Endeavour. It also describes the whole process of framing the charges against the accused, which begins by sending them a list of leading questions, and attacks the intervention by Momentum’s head, Jon Lansman, against Gregson, as well as other aspects of the witch hunt.

The article notes that since Jennie Formby took over, the mass suspensions carried out under Ian McNichol appear to have stopped. However, the adoption of the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism won’t bring this disgraceful affair to a close, but will only expand the means available to the right to accuse decent people of anti-Semitism. As its adoption was intended to.

It also discusses the protests by the local Jewish Society in Sheffield when Sheffield Labour Students invited Chris Williamson MP to talk to them. The delicate souls in the JSoc got all flustered because Williamson still associates with Jackie Walker, Ken Livingstone and Tony Greenstein, whom they have smeared as anti-Semites, and so declare that Mr. Williamson must also be one by association.

There is much more in the article, which is worth reading in its entirety. Go to:http://labourpartymarxists.org.uk/anti-zionism-and-self-censorship/

I am very glad that there is one section of the Labour party that is very firmly against this completely specious and fraudulent smear of Mike and all the other decent, anti-racist people – people like Jackie Walker, Ken Livingstone, Tony Greenstein, Martin Odoni, Cyril Chilson and so many others, as well Jewish Voice for Labour. These last have also brought down upon themselves the fury of an utterly corrupt Conservative establishment and media, including the Jewish press and Board of Deputies, for the anti-Semitic reason that they’re ‘the wrong type of Jews’.

As for Solomon and his wretched article, there are links to it in the piece by Labour Party Marxists but I deliberately didn’t read it because I knew it would only infuriate me. Of course Solomon doesn’t have any evidence that Mike’s an anti-Semite. There isn’t any because Mike isn’t. Never has been, never will be. But Solomon and his cronies, however, are thugs, bully-boys and bug-eyed racist fanatics with odious dreams of cleansing Israel of its indigenous Arabs – who have been Jewish, Muslim and Christian – and, as Tony Greenstein has shown in a recent article, are now trying to ban intermarriage between Jewish and Arab Israelis. Just like the Nazis banned marriages between ‘Aryans’ and Jews and other peoples they judged racially inferior, like Poles. And so the Zionists in this country ally themselves with other, gentile Nazi thugs like the EDL and Britain First in this country, and the Alt-Right in the US.

Mike and the others smeared by the racists of the Blairites and Israel lobby should be immediately reinstated and given groveling apologies by the party, as well as the press and media that have been complicit in this. And Cousins and the other witch-hunters themselves should face charges for racism, Thatcherite entryism and bringing the party into disrepute.

The Real News Network on the Anti-Semitism Smears and the Expulsion of Moshe Machover from Labour

October 10, 2017

The Real News Network is another great alternative news service that’s on the net. Like RT, it’s actually doing proper journalism and showing just how corrupt and unjust contemporary politics is under neoliberalism in the West. In this video, Shir Hever from Heidelberg talks to Moshe Machower, an Israeli professor and anti-Zionist activist, about his expulsion from the Labour party. Hever states that the allegations of anti-Semitism in the Labour party started shortly after Jeremy Corbyn was elected leader, and that it has become clear that they don’t have any basis in reality. They are a device to smear critics of Israel. There’s a brief clip of Jackie Walker, the Black Jewish anti-racist campaigner, who was smeared and falsely suspended as an anti-Semite because of her views on Israel’s barbarous treatment of the Palestinians, and her refusal to kowtow to the fake definition of anti-Semitism which conflates it with opposition to Israel. Walker states that the anti-Semitism smears were an entirely constructed scandal in order to bring down Corbyn.

One of the most recent victims of this witch-hunt is Professor Moshe Machower, a long time critic of Israel. Machower’s not just Jewish, but an Israeli himself. He is also a prominent mathematician and very well respected. He was expelled under the pretext that he was an anti-Semite last week because he made a very well received speech and wrote an article in the Weekly Worker making the point that anti-Zionism is not anti-Semitism. In the article he committed the heinous crime of pointing out that the Zionist organization in Nazi Germany actually welcomed the infamous Nuremberg Laws separating ‘Aryan’ and Jewish Germans in 1937.

Machower was then approached by Labour Party Marxists, who asked if they could reprint his article in their magazine. He agreed. And this is what precipitated his expulsion. The Blairites in the party used the article’s publication by the Marxists to have him ‘autoexcluded’ without any opportunity to defend himself as a Communist infiltrator. They then used the smear that he was an anti-Semite to expel the Marxist comrades, who published the article, as anti-Semites in their turn.

Machower states that this is not about anti-Semitism. It’s just a weapon in a campaign by the Blairites in the Labour party to try to cling on to power. Under Jeremy Corbyn, the Labour party has expanded to become the largest political party in Europe. Not only have new, younger members joined, but also the old ‘uns, who had previously left, disillusioned with the cynicism and Tory-lite policies of Blair and his cronies. And most of the Labour party, including Jeremy Corbyn and its top leadership, are left-wing. Hence, this isn’t a struggle in which the Labour party is trying to destroy itself, as Mr. Hever asks. It’s a struggle in which the Blairites are desperately trying to expel the Left.

I’d say here while the Blairites are trying to expel the Left from the Labour party, they have shown that they have absolutely no qualms about destroying the party in doing so. Several times there have been rumours about the Blairites wishing to split the party, and local Blairite Labour party officials have even gone so far as to ask Tories and Lib Dems to join the party to help them remove left-wing, pro-Corbyn members.

This shows how desperate they are, and how actively disloyal to the party. As well, of course, as their complete lack of morals in foully smearing decent, anti-racist, Jewish and non-Jewish men and women. And as Hever and Walker comment, their smears have been picked up by the other, competing parties and organizations outside the Labour party.

See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atfsoIqJjSo

But their smear and expulsion of Prof. Machower has not been without consequences. Tony Greenstein, another long-term Jewish critic of Zionism, and stout anti-racist and anti-Fascist campaigner, has put up a very interesting piece on his blog, reporting the mass anger that has erupted against Machower’s expulsion. So great is this discontent, that MacNicholl and the other Blairites behind Machower’s exclusion have invited him to present his case defending himself. This is in stark contrast to their earlier, summary expulsion.

I hope this is just the tip of the iceberg, and that the expulsion of Prof. Machower becomes the straw that breaks the camel’s back. It should be a step too far, and should discredit not just the smears and lies against Professor Machower, but all the lying allegations of anti-Semitism against decent people in the Labour party.

See: http://azvsas.blogspot.co.uk/2017/10/moshe-machover-explosion-of-anger-at.html

There’s another article by John Booth over at the parapolitics magazine Lobster, which also makes very clear that the anti-Semitism smears are baseless lies, used by the Blairites and the Zionist lobby in the Labour party, the Labour Friends of Israel and Jewish Labour Movement, to hang on to power. And it makes very clear in its opening paragraphs just how much these allegations differ from reality by describing the Jews active in the Labour party, or who were speaking as guests as its conference last week. He writes (footnotes included)

Anyone reading and hearing about Labour’s annual conference in Brighton might have thought it riven by yet more acrimonious controversy over antisemitism. From The Guardian to the Daily Express and the broadcast journalists in between that was the big story for those critical of the party under the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn. 1 But for those who were there or learned of it through the burgeoning alternative media, there were other impressions to be gained. The Jewish former party leader Ed Miliband appeared in relaxed mode at fringe events. 2 The keynote conference speaker was Naomi Klein, the Canadian author of Jewish descent who has done much to challenge the orthodoxies of neoliberalism and neo-conservatism. On the conference floor Jewish party 3 activist Naomi Wimbourne-Idrissi wowed delegates by her denunciation of Israeli policy on settlements and Gaza. She concluded: ‘This party does not have a problem with Jews.’ 4 Away from the formal party conference fringe, the events of the Momentum-led festival The World Transformed were routinely oversubscribed. Momentum is chaired by Jon Lansman, a former kibbutznik brought up in an Orthodox Jewish family. Later that day Wimbourne-Idrissi helped launch Jewish Voice for Labour
or 1 or <http://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/858647/labour-party-conference-2017-antisemitism-jew-brighton
or 2
3
4
(JVL) alongside international jurist Sir Stephen Sedley, Oxford emeritus 5 professor Avi Shlaim (a member of the Israel Defence Forces in 1967) and David Rosenberg of the Jewish Socialists’ Group. 6 A clue as to why the Corbyn-led Labour party has been dogged by antisemitism allegations can be found in comparing the words with which Rosenberg concluded his 2017 JVL address to a packed audience and one from a fundraiser for New Labour 15 years earlier. Here’s Rosenberg on Marek Edelman, the longest surviving member of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, who died in 2009: ‘This hero was persona non grata in Israel for remaining an anti-Zionist, and for saying about that incredible Uprising: “We fought for dignity and freedom. Not for a territory, nor for a national identity”. But the very most important thing he said was: “To be a Jew means always being with the oppressed, never with the oppressors.”’ In contrast, this is Jon (now Lord) Mendelsohn speaking to Jewsweek.com on 8 September 2002: ‘[Tony] Blair has attacked the anti-Israelism that had existed in the Labour Party . . .Labour was cowboys-and-Indians politics, picking underdogs. The milieu has changed. Zionism is pervasive in New Labour. It is automatic that Blair will come to Friends of Israel meetings.’

Another reason for the Blairites’ hatred of Corbyn is his own personal convictions. Not only has Corbyn been active in pro-Palestinian movements, but his second wife was a refugee from Pinochet’s Chile. As Blair was quite easy about providing support to every right-wing thug while trying to mask it under liberal platitudes, it’s not surprising that Mandelson and the others should be bitterly opposed to someone who takes standing up for human rights very seriously.

For more information, see:file:///C:/Users/User/lob74-labour-corbyn-anti-semitism.pdf