Posts Tagged ‘Hillsdale College’

Talk By Journalist Abigail Shrier Attacking the Trans Craze and Its Pseudoscience

July 13, 2022

But again, not transpeople themselves. This is another video that does an excellent job of attacking the faulty science and mental pathologies behind the alarming growth in girls and young women, who now believe they’re trans and are seeking medical help and transition. Shrier herself isn’t a doctor or psychiatrist, but a journalist who was asked to look into this phenomenon by friends. They were going through the immense problem of having a daughter declare herself trans, and were concerned that no-one else was covering it. So Shrier looked into it, eventually publishing a book “Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters”. Shrier gives her presentation at Hillsdale College. She starts by describing herself as a social conservative, and her audience appears to be composed of conservative Christians. Some of them openly declare during the question and answer session that they believe the transgender craze to be actively demonic. Her cool silence when they do suggests that she may be an atheist. She doesn’t share their religious beliefs, but she is very appreciative of the warm support they give her.

Shrier also is very keen to make a clear distinction between transpeople and the trans rights activists. She has trans friends, whom she describes as the warmest, kindest, nicest people. This is in sharp contrast with the vicious intolerance of the trans rights activists, who have tried to get her book banned. The trans rights activists try to silence their critics through abuse, death threats and doxing on twitter, very aggressive and intimidating counter demonstrations, and by threatening scientists, doctors, medical professionals, journalists and other critics with accusations of transphobia with the consequent danger of losing their jobs.

She argues that the increase in trans identified girls is a social contagion, rather than women who genuinely have the condition simply coming forward because social prejudice against trans people has eased. This is because previously there were very few referrals for gender treatment and the majority of these were from boys and men. Now the vast majority of young women. If this was also a case of naturally occurring gender dysphoria, there would also be a corresponding rise in older women, and particularly older men coming forward as well. This has not happened according to her. Most of the audience, including doctors and psychologists agree, although one scientists stands up at the end to declare that they are seeing a corresponding increase in these groups. Shrier does accept that she cannot know what might have occurred, if the culture was different.

She also believes that it’s a social contagion because of its similarity to other social psychological disorder like anorexia and bulimia, which particularly affect girls and young women. Women form networks amongst their friends, which share and take on each other’s pain. And so these friends may also become infected with their friends’ psychological ailments. She states that hospitals keep women with eating disorders apart, as they encourage themselves to lose weight. The classic pattern for the girls and young women declaring that they are trans are typically that they have no previous history of transgenderism. They don’t identify as boys during their childhood, and there is nothing that suggests that they secretly do. Then they discover the trans sites on the internet, or make friends at university with other girls, who believe they’re trans, and so come to believe that they also are really boys in the wrong body.

One of the questions she’s asked is whether her own book is skewed towards the gender critical side, and she talked to more people from that side of the debate than those who supported conventional pro-trans explanation. She replies by stating that she went out to talk to both and original didn’t have any preconceived ideas about it.

Shrier has appeared on a number of other videos being interviewed by Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson and others. She’s well worth listening to on this issue. The videos nearly an hour long at 58 mins so you may be able to only catch a small slice of it.