Trotsky on the Failure of Capitalism

I found this quote from Trotsky on how capitalism has now outlived its usefulness as a beneficial economic system in Isaac Deutscher and George Novack, The Age of Permanent Revolution: A Trotsky Anthology (New York: Dell 1964):

Capitalism has outlived itself as a world system. It has ceased to fulfill its essential function, the raising of the level of human power and human wealth. Humanity cannot remain stagnant at the level which it has reached. Only a powerful increase in productive force and a sound, planned, that is, socialist organisation of production and distribution can assure humanity – all humanity – of a decent standard of life and at the same time give it the precious feeling of freedom with respect to its own economy. (p. 363).

I’m not a fan of Trotsky. Despite the protestations to the contrary from the movement he founded, I think he was during his time as one of the leaders of the Russian Revolution and civil war ruthless and authoritarian. The Soviet Union under his leadership may not have been as massively murderous as Stalin’s regime, but it seems to me that it would still have been responsible for mass deaths and imprisonment on a huge scale.

He was also very wrong in his expectation of the collapse of capitalism and the outbreak of revolution in the Developed World. As an orthodox Marxist, he wanted to export the Communist revolution to the rest of Europe, and believed that it would be in the most developed countries of the capitalist West, England, France, and Germany, that revolution would also break out. He also confidently expected throughout his career the imminent collapse of capitalism. This didn’t happen, partly because of the reforms and welfare states established by reformist socialist parties like Labour in Britain and the SPD in Germany, which improved workers’ lives and opportunities, which thus allowed them to stimulate the capitalist economy as consumers and gave them a stake in preserving the system.

It also seems to me that capitalism is still actively creating wealth – the rich are still becoming massively richer – and it is benefiting those countries in the Developing World, which have adopted it, like China and the east Asian ‘tiger’ economies like South Korea.

But in the west neoliberalism, unregulated capitalism, certainly has failed. It hasn’t brought public services, like electricity, railways, and water supply the investment they need, and has been repeatedly shown to be far more inefficient in the provision of healthcare. And it is pushing more and more people into grinding poverty, so denying them the ability to play a role as active citizens about to make wide choices about the jobs they can take, what leisure activities they can choose, and the goods they can buy. At the moment the Tories are able to hide its colossal failure by hiding the mounting evidence and having their hacks in the press pump out favourable propaganda. But if the situation carries on as it is, sooner or later the mass poverty they’ve created will not be so easily hidden or blithely explained away or blamed on others – immigrants, the poor themselves, or the EU. You don’t have to be a Trotskyite to believe the following:

Unfettered capitalism is destroying Britain – get rid of it, and the Tories.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

3 Responses to “Trotsky on the Failure of Capitalism”

  1. trev Says:

    Thing is though, the system is rigged, Capitalism did fail in the form of the Banking crash between 2008 – 2010, but the Government then used our money to bail them out! And we’re all still paying for it in the form of Austerity. Some say the crash was caused by the Ponzi scheme set up by George W. Bush that lead to the collapse of the American sub-prime mortgage market, in which vulture Capitalists made fortunes from lending to anyone regardless and selling on the debts up to 15 times or more. Such abuses of Capital are unsustainable and immoral, bound to collapse. Neoliberalism and Austerity has spiralled the wealth upwards to the richest, and made everyone else poorer. Capitalism needs to be responsibly regulated, and essential services such as Utilities, Transport and Communications need to be Nationalized.

  2. sdbast Says:

    Reblogged this on sdbast.

  3. Florence Says:

    The death rattles of capitalism in the form of neoliberalism is now voraciously gobbling up available remaining resources through appropriation of the New Green Deal. Carbon credit trading is even more of a ponzi scheme than mortgages and doesn’t even need a notional tangible asset base. It is a simple transfer of wealth from the many to the few, based on a bit of good old shock doctrine. We see the XR and its ilk as doing the heavy lifting, ensuring an entire generation is emotionally wedded to unproven “science” and willingly offering up their sacrifice of lower living standards and “traded carbon credits” which of course is just a poor mans tax.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: