Vox Political on the Government’s Privatisation of the Prisons

Mike yesterday also put up a piece on Vox Political from the Canary, reporting that the government is planning a stealth privatisation of the prison system. They’re to be transformed into independent ‘reform prisons’, which can set their own wages and conditions for staff and inmates. It’s very much like the government’s stealth privatisation of the schools by transforming them into academies, especially as it’s being done by Michael Gove, the same person, who masterminded the school programme.

The Canary reported:

In the Queen’s speech on Wednesday, the government announced its new prison and courts reform bill. At the heart of the bill is the creation of several new “autonomous reform prisons” which, says the government:

“will give unprecedented freedoms to prison governors, including financial and legal freedoms, such as how the prison budget is spent and whether to opt-out of national contracts; and operational freedoms over education, the prison regime, family visits, and partnerships to provide prison work and rehabilitation services.”

It’s hardly necessary to say that business opportunities and profits also loom large in the Tory plans:

And, as with academies, the prison reforms will open up commercial opportunities for those in charge of them. Prison governors will have “unprecedented operational and financial autonomy”, says David Cameron. They will be given “total discretion over how to spend” their budgets. They will be able to “opt-out of national contracts and choose their own suppliers”. And, just to be clear, “we’ll ensure there is a strong role for businesses and charities in the operation of these Reform Prisons”.

There are a number of privately-run prisons in America, and these have been the subject of a number of scandals. As for-profit institutions, they do exploit prison labour, and lobby lawmakers and judges in their states to pass harsh anti-crime legislation and punishments, which will maximise the number sent to prisons. It’s very much like the old Stalinist system, where the gulags – the forced labour camps to which dissidents were sent – were used to industrialise the USSR. Local industry leaders gave the NKVD a list of the types of workers they needed, and the forerunner of the KGB then came round and arrested a few imperialist/Trotskyist/Fascist running dogs. Exactly the same is going to happen here.

The scandal has been covered by Michael Moore in his film, Capitalism: A Love Story, where he reports on the case of a teenage girl, who was sentenced to prison for what was basically just truancy. The judge, who sentenced her was in the pay of one of the private prison corporations.

And in America, the prisoners themselves have begun to strike back against what they see as their exploitation.

In the piece below from RT, their anchor talks to Jim Del Duca of the Incarcerated Workers Organising Committee about a strike by inmates in a Texas prison against their exploitation. Del Duca explains that the 13th amendment, which abolished slavery in the United States, did not do so for prisons. They see themselves very much as America’s new slaves. They’re paid 5 cents an hour for their work. This is not for the taxpayer, and the money saved does not go back to the state. Rather, it goes to the private corporations, who use prison labour. These include a wide range of industries, including construction, and the defence industry. Del Duca points out that the defence industry receives vast amounts of government funding and is immensely profitable. For the prisoners themselves, conditions are very different. Del Duca discusses the problem of overcrowding and increasing numbers of prisoners being crammed into gaols that simply weren’t built to hold that number. He also says that phone calls to family are immensely expensive, and if a prisoner wants to make a phone call for medical aid, this will cost him $100.

Finally, they discuss how members of the public can help the striking prisoners. Del Duca and his fellows are members of the Industrial Workers of the World, the Wobblies, a documentary on whom I posted up on this blog not so long ago. People can support the strike by joining the union, getting in touch with the striking workers, or simply refusing to buy goods produced by prison slave labour.

I have to say I find the prospect of prisoners going on strike bizarre and faintly comical, like something from some of the comedies of the 1970s commenting on strikes and industrial unrest in that decade. But there are serious issues here about the humane treatment of prisoners, the balance between punishment and rehabilitation, and simply not getting profit through slave labour.

Back in the 1920s the radical playwright and author, Antonin Artaud issued a manifesto for the Surrealists. In it, he urged the people to rise up, and open up the prisons and the lunatic asylums. This is going way too far, and the last thing anyone wants is more thugs, rapists, murderers, muggers, fraudsters and thieves running around. We’ve got far too many of those in the House of Commons as it is. But when faced with the grim exploitation of for-profit private prisons, you can see his point.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

6 Responses to “Vox Political on the Government’s Privatisation of the Prisons”

  1. philippajanebrown777 Says:

    I’d like to tweet and glog (post to google) your posts. Why don’t you have the buttons?

    • beastrabban Says:

      I’m not really tech-savvy, and so really don’t know how to put them on. I’m not on Twitter, though I do have Google. I started trying to put the buttons on, but got a certain way before it all became a bit too much for me. Sorry to sound so pathetic, but it’s true. If you’ve got any advice on how to do it, let me know. 🙂

  2. vondreassen Says:

    Reblogged this on vondreassen and commented:
    I like your final paragraph ! SO TRUE !

  3. Florence Says:

    It won’t be riding like those on the USA, it will in all likelyhood be the same companies from over there being given contracts over here. Or total amateurs like Virgin.

  4. joanna Says:

    Hi Beast I’m sorry for being off- topic, but I have been told about a website called “Do it” It is full of voluntary jobs, a lot of what used to be paid!!

    I find it very disturbing that volunteers are needed for jobs that used to have a proper wage attached to them.

    If someone is working a voluntary job, then, when would they have the time to have a paid job, As far as I know volunteers do not pay income tax, so where would that money come from?

    This government have shot themselves in the foot, because without jobs there is no income tax to be collected, apart from making working peoples, and VAT taxes higher!

    On the “Do it” Website there are many jobs that used to be paid occupations, yet what are people meant to live on whilst they are doing these “voluntary jobs”.

    Ok, so the government wants to bring down the benefits bill, but how can that ever be achieved when previously paid jobs are being thrown at the voluntary sector? They cannot have their cake and eat it, people need to be able to live and taxes need to be raised.

    Even “Maslow’s hierarchy of needs” has been thrown out of the window, as has this quote, “A nation’s greatness is measured by how it treats its weakest members.” Mahatma Gandhi.

    With regards to benefits, only JSA is taxable, both ESA groups do not qualify.

    I am totally rubbish at maths, among many other things, but even I can see the glaring hole in this piece of IL-logic!

    • beastrabban Says:

      I think you’re absolutely right, Joanna. It isn’t joined-up thinking, but I don’t think a lot of thinking has been done about these policies anyway. It’s like the unpaid internships that are now being offered to young hopefuls wishing to start a career in particular professions, like journalism. It’s part of a management ‘something-for-nothing’ culture, in which businesses and charities expect to get free labour by dressing unpaid work up as some kind of great opportunity. And the rhetoric about it is always the same. No, you won’t be paid, but it will be valuable experience. With some of the voluntary work, I expect that they don’t realise, or actually aren’t bothered, by the requirement on the jobseeker to spend every moment looking for a job. Some of these voluntary jobs are probably aimed at retired people; the same retired people, who were expected to step in and run the libraries and the other public services the government have cut. Or perhaps they’re looking for people on workfare to be referred to them. But you’re absolutely right: it doesn’t make sense, except to greedy employers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: